Debunking McGuintonomics

So last week Alison Redford the Premier of Alberta asked Ontario’s Premier Dalton McGuinty to show some public support for the Oil Sands, currently facing a heap of criticism from environmentalists. No one knows what Mrs. Redford was expecting as a response, in any case the answer sounded a little bit like “If Alberta didn’t exists Ontario would be better off”. His conclusion was based on the popular belief that the Canadian dollar had become a ‘PetroDollar’ and that it’s meteoric rise had crushed Ontario’s manufacturing base. Now because McGuinty and his family seem to be career politicians we will pardon his ignorance of economics and try to fill some of his knowledge gap.

So McGuinty thinks a high dollar is bad. First mistake. Very broadly speaking a relatively high currency is a mark of wealth. Basically the World wants to buy our stuff more than we want to buy the worlds stuff. Okay so foreigners recognize that we are a nice country worth investing in and who’s products look alright, but if you still believe a high currency is killing jobs in manufacturing well that would seem like a mightily expensive accolade. However Ontario is not innocent in this. Unfortunately the worlds appreciation of fiscal virtuousness is quite lagged to reality by a couple crises. So when Canada starts supplying the World with all our AAA rated (and less well rated but ‘made in Canada’ stamped debt) in an environment where some of the deepest debt markets are not nearly as risk free as they used to be, obviously foreign investors gobble it up our debt greedily. What is the effect of that? well essentially the world values our debt more than our goods and services, so when that appetite for financial assets inflates the Canadian dollar, our exports will suffer (see the US current account deficit/reserve currency status/trade deficit quagmire). Now since Alberta doesn’t have any debt and hasn’t issued some for a while they can’t be guilty on that front. So who is exactly contributing to our soaring Looney from a financial assets trade perspective? The feds are! Alright since much of the stimulus package was spent in Ontario (G8/G20 summit spending, carmakers bailouts etc, etc…) maybe McGuinty should move to accuse the second biggest  new Canadian debt emitter… oh wait a minute, that’s Ontario, oops. So McGuinty’s spending problem is partly to blame for a high Canadian dollar not Alberta. Okay in all fairness international financial assets trade is not the only contributing factor to currency mouvements so let’s move on.

The gist of McGuinty’s argument was that Albertan energy sales are increasing the value of the CAD to the detriment of manufacturing. So he is implying that their is a a negative correlation between manufacturing exports and energy exports. That data does not support this claim one bit! When looking at seasonally adjusted and 2002 chained dollars (inflation adjusted) Canadian total energy product sales have risen by 24% since 2000 and total manufacturing (sum of statscan’s industrial goods, manufacturing and equipment, automotive parts categories) have gone down by 14% over the same periode would imply the Premier is right, However when looking at proportions the increase in energy sales is only of 40 billion yearly versus a 125 billion drop for total manufacturing. So basically if there actually was a one-for-one tradeoff between energy and manufacturing exports energy would only be responsible for ~32% of the decline. However when one looks at balance of trade in those subcategories and asks what percentage of net energy exports accounts for the decline of net manufacturing exports the answer is a measly ~4.5%. So to reiterate if there even was causality (which is not proven) it would be weak at best. Now that we’ve lain waste to McGuinty’s foolish idea that Alberta is guilty for his province’s hard times, let’s bring up one more point.

Ontario is now a have-not province. Ontario received upwards of 3 Billion dollars last year from equalization transfers. Alberta paid in over 8 Billion into equalization. Bottom line Ontario got some money from Alberta to pay for its social services. Methinks McGuinty owes Redford and Albertans an apology, don’t you?