Greece! Go Away!

I sometimes shiver with humiliation at the memories of my adolescence and the utter immaturity that characterized them. I comfort myself with the thought that I have outgrown them. I used to believe that people outgrew their baser adolescent instincts of selfishness, laziness and general disdain for responsibility, I could not phantom the possibility that an entire populace could degenerate into a mindless mob of collective adolescents. Greece has proved me oh so wrong. Now before anybody get’s up and antsy about the broad generalization I recognize that not all greeks are in the streets hooded in black and throwing fiery cocktails around. However, the despairing state of the Greek economy is the business of all those people and the general result of their cumulative collective decisions. The guilty parties are, in no particular order: tax evaders, union leaders and members, politicians, savers, voters, anarchists, socialists, wannabe monopolists, retirees, students and anyone silent on the going-ons of the county. That list I believe covers more or less the majority of the people from the small nation that gave the world democracy.

Reading up on the back and forth between Athens, the Troika and various European capitals I’ll admit to a sinking feeling of despair. Berlin’s demands just keep mounting and the absurdity of Greek politics never retreats. German flags are being burned in the streets of Greece, right-wing papers in the country compare Merkel to a Nazi while across the divide any remaining AAA country in the Euro are simply loosing interest in Greece who has proved a most unreliable partner in the battle for economic stability.

I’m no Keynesian but the repeated bouts of austerity demanded by Greece’s Euro creditors are pummelling the periphery’s economies harshly. I don’t believe I’ve ever heard a Monetarist or even an Austrian economist recommend pro-cyclical fiscal policy systemically. Austrians economists might say that recessions are good because they kill bad business models permitting the flowering of sustainable industry. However even the most die-hard fiscal hawks (me) have to admit that at an above 6% contraction yearly with no hope in sight for growth, even good businesses will flounder. That’s why fiscal consolidation in Greece needs to be accompanied by stimulus spending funded by the competitive parts of Europe. Pan-European unemployment insurance is the most sensible proposal that has not gone main stream yet. The moral hazard that will ensue is undeniable but until permanent mechanisms for intra-Euro fiscal transfers can be worked out, the benefits are surely worth the cost.

That said that the money masters’ responses to continued contraction in the periphery are inadequate, the reaction from the patients are increasingly unacceptable. In Italy the unions responses to the Monti plan for liberalization are tantamount to the summum of Human selfishness. While the house is burning the unions are trying to save their clothes while some are still trapped (the unemployed) admittedly while some have already fled (the tax evaders). The retired are equally deserving of blame silent on the whole affaire so long as their golden retirements are not threatened even when these same retirement plans are bankrupting their nation. But while Spain and Italy’s yields come down showing the markets forgiving side, or just the ECB vast manipulation skills, Greece and Portugal edge towards the brink. While tame in Lisbon, reactions in Athens are flaring up to an extreme.

I long ago learned that the most vociferous voices rarely represent or even understand the silent majority. The silent majority in most western countries are hard working middle class and relatively rational voters. Even when they are swindled into voting for a party that ill benefits their country’s these voters always (almost) correct their aim sending back their political systems to the center. This does not seem to be happening in Greece. Not only has the majority let its political leaders lead them to a path of reckless fiscal irresponsibility and stupidity, they now seem unwilling to admit to the wrongness of their ways. For God’s sake Greece’s politicians are asking to be the least trusted west of Tehran. Its anarchist youth are trying to give 80’s Italian terrorist youths a run for their money. To reverse an oft heard insult, the Greeks’ silent majority is about to be hoodwinked into poverty faster than Germans were into Nazism. Greeks have committed the cardinal sin of fiscal profligacy, they have been found guilty by the markets, they are now in a liquidity and solvency jail. The rest of Europe has posted bail, and now has promised to take Greece into a pseudo form of receivership in order to buy the fledging country a little decency and freedom. Greek response to the modest conditions demanded of it, spitting in the AAA’s faces. The audacity and hypocrisy demonstrated in the land of classical drama is baffling to say the least and shockingly amoral.

While I wish a speedy recovery for all of Europe and hope that the beauty of the European project can be furthered, I’d be lying if I didn’t say I believe the Greeks have lost all rights to participate in the next chapter of Europe’s history.